further fuel for the fires of controversy

Quilting Forum - All about quilts and other quilted items. 

Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
further fuel for the fires of controversy John 06-15-2007
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by John on June 15, 2007, 6:28 pm
I was looking at some of the older postings and one came up that
concerned what is a "Real" quilt. Is it one made with hand stitched
top or can a machine stitched be considered as valid. One of the
features of my new computer is a Dictionary and so I ran the word
Quilt thru the query window of this Dictionary which is the Oxford
American Dictionary.

quilt [kwilt]
noun
a warm bed covering made of padding enclosed between layers of fabric
and kept in place by lines of stitching, typically applied in a
decorative design.
a knitted or fabric bedspread with decorative stitching.
a layer of padding used for insulation.

verb [trans.]
join together (layers of fabric or padding) with lines of stitching to
form a bed covering or warm garment, of for decorative effect.

quilt-er [noun]

ORIGIN Middle English: from old French cuilte, from Latin culcita
'mattress, cushion'


Thesaurus


quilt
noun
DUVET, cover(s), coverlet, comforter, bedspread; dated counterpane


That is the end of the definitions. I note that there is no mention of
the hand or machine method of construction.
Of course, there may be another dictionary definition but that is good
enough for me, and enough of a reference to anyone who is questioning
the authenticity of whatever type of quilting one does to achieve the
finished quilt. Nuff Said.

John


Posted by Sherry on June 15, 2007, 6:53 pm
> I was looking at some of the older postings and one came up that
> concerned what is a "Real" quilt. Is it one made with hand stitched
> top or can a machine stitched be considered as valid. One of the
> features of my new computer is a Dictionary and so I ran the word
> Quilt thru the query window of this Dictionary which is the Oxford
> American Dictionary.
>
> quilt [kwilt]
> noun
> a warm bed covering made of padding enclosed between layers of fabric
> and kept in place by lines of stitching, typically applied in a
> decorative design.
> a knitted or fabric bedspread with decorative stitching.
> a layer of padding used for insulation.
>
> verb [trans.]
> join together (layers of fabric or padding) with lines of stitching to
> form a bed covering or warm garment, of for decorative effect.
>
> quilt-er [noun]
>
> ORIGIN Middle English: from old French cuilte, from Latin culcita
> 'mattress, cushion'
>
> Thesaurus
>
> quilt
> noun
> DUVET, cover(s), coverlet, comforter, bedspread; dated counterpane
>
> That is the end of the definitions. I note that there is no mention of
> the hand or machine method of construction.
> Of course, there may be another dictionary definition but that is good
> enough for me, and enough of a reference to anyone who is questioning
> the authenticity of whatever type of quilting one does to achieve the
> finished quilt. Nuff Said.
>
> John

Yup. They're real quilts all right.
Except I don't care what the dictionary says, those $29 bedcoverings
that say "handquilted" aren't real quilts.
The ones that feel like someone took 5 cotton balls and stretched them
out far enough to suffice for batting.
They *are* hand quilted. Probably by some poor child earning six cents
a day in some third-world country.
$29 quilts bother me on a whole lot of levels.

Sherry


Posted by John on June 15, 2007, 7:10 pm
>
>
>
> > I was looking at some of the older postings and one came up that
> > concerned what is a "Real" quilt. Is it one made with hand stitched
> > top or can a machine stitched be considered as valid. One of the
> > features of my new computer is a Dictionary and so I ran the word
> > Quilt thru the query window of this Dictionary which is the Oxford
> > American Dictionary.
>
> > quilt [kwilt]
> > noun
> > a warm bed covering made of padding enclosed between layers of fabric
> > and kept in place by lines of stitching, typically applied in a
> > decorative design.
> > a knitted or fabric bedspread with decorative stitching.
> > a layer of padding used for insulation.
>
> > verb [trans.]
> > join together (layers of fabric or padding) with lines of stitching to
> > form a bed covering or warm garment, of for decorative effect.
>
> > quilt-er [noun]
>
> > ORIGIN Middle English: from old French cuilte, from Latin culcita
> > 'mattress, cushion'
>
> > Thesaurus
>
> > quilt
> > noun
> > DUVET, cover(s), coverlet, comforter, bedspread; dated counterpane
>
> > That is the end of the definitions. I note that there is no mention of
> > the hand or machine method of construction.
> > Of course, there may be another dictionary definition but that is good
> > enough for me, and enough of a reference to anyone who is questioning
> > the authenticity of whatever type of quilting one does to achieve the
> > finished quilt. Nuff Said.
>
> > John
>
> Yup. They're real quilts all right.
> Except I don't care what the dictionary says, those $29 bedcoverings
> that say "handquilted" aren't real quilts.
> The ones that feel like someone took 5 cotton balls and stretched them
> out far enough to suffice for batting.
> They *are* hand quilted. Probably by some poor child earning six cents
> a day in some third-world country.
> $29 quilts bother me on a whole lot of levels.
>
> Sherry

I agree. They bother me on a socio-economic level but non the less by
definition they are quilts. Probably better defined as slave labor
quilts rather than hand stitched.

John


Posted by Taria on June 15, 2007, 7:12 pm
Now Sherry, Those 29$ quilts are real quilts until you wash
them and they fall apart! Then they are rags.
Taria

Sherry wrote:

>
>
> Yup. They're real quilts all right.
> Except I don't care what the dictionary says, those $29 bedcoverings
> that say "handquilted" aren't real quilts.
> The ones that feel like someone took 5 cotton balls and stretched them
> out far enough to suffice for batting.
> They *are* hand quilted. Probably by some poor child earning six cents
> a day in some third-world country.
> $29 quilts bother me on a whole lot of levels.
>
> Sherry
>


Posted by KJ on June 15, 2007, 7:18 pm
applause! Great answer!

--
Kathyl (KJ)
remove "nospam" before mchsi
http://community.webshots.com/user/kathylquiltz
> Now Sherry, Those 29$ quilts are real quilts until you wash
> them and they fall apart! Then they are rags.
> Taria
>
> Sherry wrote:
>
>>
>>
>> Yup. They're real quilts all right.
>> Except I don't care what the dictionary says, those $29 bedcoverings
>> that say "handquilted" aren't real quilts.
>> The ones that feel like someone took 5 cotton balls and stretched them
>> out far enough to suffice for batting.
>> They *are* hand quilted. Probably by some poor child earning six cents
>> a day in some third-world country.
>> $29 quilts bother me on a whole lot of levels.
>>
>> Sherry
>>
>



Similar ThreadsPosted
OT Brush Fires in FL May 8, 2007, 6:24 am
OT: Sunday fires April 27, 2008, 5:52 pm
OT Wild Fires in Florida May 2, 2007, 6:14 pm
Florida wild fires May 13, 2007, 7:30 pm
Prayers for California Fires October 23, 2007, 9:51 pm
More fires..... this time in Arizona... July 4, 2008, 3:47 pm
Tues night update Fires and wind October 23, 2007, 10:00 pm

Contact Us | Privacy Policy
Sewgirls.com XML SitemapXML Sitemap