Workable to alter a 44L to a 44R mens jacket. Would the pockets not come too low ?

Sewing Discussions - A group that is not as it seams. 

Page 1 of 2       1 2 > last >> Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Workable to alter a 44L to a 44R mens jacket. Would the pockets not come too low ? Veronica 04-22-2007
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by Veronica on April 22, 2007, 11:06 pm
Workable to alter a 44L to a 44R mens jacket. Would the pockets not
come too low on the coat ? I see many 44L Jackets for sale, but do not
know if the 44L can be altered to a 44R without the pockets problem ?

My man would be happy if this were workable. Taking 1 - 2 inches off
the bottom of a suit jacket is not that much of a problem, but the
balance of the jacket and the pockets....

well, over to you (thanks)

Posted by BEI Design on April 23, 2007, 1:55 am
Veronica wrote:
> Workable to alter a 44L to a 44R mens jacket. Would the
> pockets not come too low on the coat ? I see many 44L
> Jackets for sale, but do not know if the 44L can be
> altered to a 44R without the pockets problem ?
>
> My man would be happy if this were workable. Taking 1 - 2
> inches off the bottom of a suit jacket is not that much
> of a problem, but the balance of the jacket and the
> pockets....
>
> well, over to you (thanks)

I think it would have to be *very cheap* (as in free) to justify
all the work involved: in addition to "Taking 1 - 2 off the
bottom" you'd have to shorten the lining (if there is one), and
hemming up the bottom would leave the back vent(s) way to short
so you'd probably have to sew them closed, which might destroy
the look. Then you would probably have to shorten the sleeves,
sleeve lining, and sleeve vents, and move the buttons (or, more
properly, shorten the sleeves from both the sleeve cap *and* the
hem so that the elbow stays in the proper position). And if the
pockets are welt pockets, there's not anything you could do about
their being too low. If they are patch pockets, you could take
them off, and sew them 2" higher while the lining was unstitched.
But the waistline shaping would not be at the right position, the
front button(s) would not be closing where it/they should.

That would involve an awful lot of unpicking, sewing, and cussing
for me. I would not take it on. I'd *much* prefer making a
complete jacket from scratch.

But, have your guy try the jacket(s) on, and stand back and see
if the whole thing seems to "fit" except for the bottom hem (that
is, the sleeves, waist, lapels, etc). If the bottom length is
*the only thing* which needs altering it *might* be worth it...to
you.

Beverly, who loves sewing from scratch, loathes alterations.




Posted by BEI Design on April 23, 2007, 2:15 am
BEI Design wrote:

> back vent(s) way to short so you'd probably have to sew

Aaaargh! That should have been "too", not "to".

Sorry! Must..... go..... to.... bed..........

Beverly



Posted by Veronica on April 24, 2007, 12:45 pm
On Sun, 22 Apr 2007 22:55:35 -0700, "BEI Design"

>Veronica wrote:
>> Workable to alter a 44L to a 44R mens jacket. Would the
>> pockets not come too low on the coat ? I see many 44L
>> Jackets for sale, but do not know if the 44L can be
>> altered to a 44R without the pockets problem ?
>>
>> My man would be happy if this were workable. Taking 1 - 2
>> inches off the bottom of a suit jacket is not that much
>> of a problem, but the balance of the jacket and the
>> pockets....
>>
>> well, over to you (thanks)
>
>I think it would have to be *very cheap* (as in free) to justify
>all the work involved: in addition to "Taking 1 - 2 off the
>bottom" you'd have to shorten the lining (if there is one), and
>hemming up the bottom would leave the back vent(s) way to short
>so you'd probably have to sew them closed, which might destroy
>the look. Then you would probably have to shorten the sleeves,
>sleeve lining, and sleeve vents, and move the buttons (or, more
>properly, shorten the sleeves from both the sleeve cap *and* the
>hem so that the elbow stays in the proper position). And if the
>pockets are welt pockets, there's not anything you could do about
>their being too low. If they are patch pockets, you could take
>them off, and sew them 2" higher while the lining was unstitched.
>But the waistline shaping would not be at the right position, the
>front button(s) would not be closing where it/they should.
>
>That would involve an awful lot of unpicking, sewing, and cussing
>for me. I would not take it on. I'd *much* prefer making a
>complete jacket from scratch.
>
>But, have your guy try the jacket(s) on, and stand back and see
>if the whole thing seems to "fit" except for the bottom hem (that
>is, the sleeves, waist, lapels, etc). If the bottom length is
>*the only thing* which needs altering it *might* be worth it...to
>you.
>
>Beverly, who loves sewing from scratch, loathes alterations.
>
>
This is very helpful, informative and appreciated. I simply was not
aware that so much resolution would be in order to accomplish the
task. Just cutting and "sewing up" the desired amount of fabric is not
going to be acceptable from what I am now enlightened regarding.
VJ

Posted by BEI Design on April 24, 2007, 1:43 pm
Veronica wrote:
> This is very helpful, informative and appreciated. I
> simply was not aware that so much resolution would be in
> order to accomplish the task. Just cutting and "sewing
> up" the desired amount of fabric is not going to be
> acceptable from what I am now enlightened regarding.
> VJ

A man's suit jacket is a work of art. There is an amazing amount
of hand stitching on the inside that you never even see, but that
contributes enormously to how the jacket fits, hangs, wears, etc.
I made a three piece suit for my DH several years ago and at that
time I bought several books on *real* tailoring. I had sewn a
great deal up to that point but I found I did not know *anything*
about how a man's jacket is constructed. It is much different
than a woman's suit for instance.

If you really want to alter a man's RTW jacket, I would recommend
taking a look at your local library for some guidance.

Beverly



Page 1 of 2       1 2 > last >>
Similar ThreadsPosted
How to alter a baby dress? December 28, 2006, 6:01 am
How to alter a baby dress? - Thanks for help January 13, 2007, 3:10 am
Trouser Side Pockets June 13, 2006, 12:37 am
prosthesis pockets in bras June 17, 2007, 7:36 pm
Jacket or.... January 3, 2006, 10:46 pm
jacket on me February 18, 2008, 4:33 pm
altering a tux jacket February 20, 2006, 10:25 am
Need help with jacket pattern I am trying to use September 2, 2006, 1:54 am
Help altering a jacket.... May 7, 2007, 10:20 pm
Big Men's Jacket... October 8, 2007, 4:07 pm

Contact Us | Privacy Policy
Sewgirls.com XML SitemapXML Sitemap